Should Medicare premium information be shared with PPO providers?

CMS and the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI), in an effort to provide a more coordinated and satisfactory patient experience when it comes to the delivery of healthcare services, has placed much focus on improving Medicare program transparency around access to services, provider quality measures, clinical outcomes and fair pricing. 

It is fair to ask whether or not providers – who are responsible for the delivery of clinical diagnosis and treatment to Medicare beneficiaries – should have knowledge about the beneficiaries’ benefit plan and premium costs, including copayments and coinsurance. There is reasonable argument on both sides of this issue regarding patient privacy, the right to know or not know, as well as the opinion that a provider or supplier does not need to know a beneficiary’s premium payments to price the service or item provided.

Those in favor of providing provider and suppliers with premium information might suggest that the information helps the provider find less expensive treatment alternatives when the benefit plan and related financial requirements would otherwise prove problematic. Others would opine that the provider’s number one concern should be the patient’s needs and hoped-for outcome.  

There is, however, another reason that it might make sense to share premium information with providers and suppliers: Providers, like the patient, usually do not appreciate the financial relationship between the monthly dollar amount assigned to each patient for provision of medical care and the actual cost charged for providing that medical care.  Knowing that relationship may have the desired effect of providers, suppliers and the patient agreeing on a treatment approach that is more judicious regarding the ordering of procedures, tests and supplies that may not be necessary in every case for the desired treatment outcomes.

At the end of the day there is a limit to the financial resources available for the funding of medical services. If everyone involved in the provison of medical services and supplies understands those limitations, then decisions on how those resources are expended may beome more measured without sacrificing service quality or treatment outcomes.